Review of Acid Throwing Crime: How to Punishment, Methods of Prevention

Fatemi, MJ

Review of Acid Throwing Crime: How to Punishment, Methods of Prevention

Document Type : Review Article

Author

MJ Fatemi

Professor of Plastic & Reconstructive Surgery, Burn Research Center, Iran University of Medical Sciences, Hazrate Fateme Hospital, Tehran, Iran

Abstract

Acid throwing as a formidable violence is more common in countries such as India, Bangladesh, Cambodia and Pakistan. There is a close connection between acid throwing crime and the social status of women. Regarding the irreparable damage of this crime and, more importantly, destroying the beauty of the victim's face, for some people, it is even heavier than the offense of intentional murder. Since acid throwing has been spread in Iran in recent years, a comparative study of punishment of this crime in Iran with these four countries, according to their legal system, appears to be useful. Therefore, type, quality and quantity of punishment and penalizing the criminal can be helpful in better understanding of criminal law, using strengths and covering weaknesses in legislation. According to the results of this study, there is no enough standard law in this country to deter acid throwing. Accordingly, its production, distribution and sale should be limited and preventable, and its illegal distribution must be punished. Since acid throwing is rarely fatal but causes serious damage to one's appearance and beauty, death penalty is rarely imposed. It is important to note that acid burn is a lifelong disease therefore criminal must incur all of conventional expenses of victim for a lifetime in addition to the wergild.

Keywords

Crime

Acid Throwing

Punishment

1. Sharma DC. India promises to curb acid attacks. The Lancet. 2013 Sep 21; 382(9897):1013.

2. Pillay VV; Corrosive (Caustic Poisons). Modern Medical Toxicology, 4 edition, Jaypee, New Delhi, 2013: 39-40.

3. Vij K; Corrosive Poisons. In Text Book of Forensic Medicine and Toxicology Principles and Practice, 5 thedition, Elsevier, India, 2003: 462.

4. Yeasmeen MN. Acid Attack in the Back Drop of India and Criminal Amendment Act, 2013.

5. فلاح ماکرانی، اویس. بررسی علل بروز جرم اسیدپاشی از منظر قانون و جامعه. پایگاه نشر مقالات حقوقی و حق گستر (اردیبهشت 1391).

6. Patel M. A desire to disfigure: acid attack in India. International journal of criminology and sociological theory. 2014 Dec; 7(2): e39702.

7. Mittal P, Dhattarwal SK. Vitriolage: The curse of human origin. History. 2014; 6(21): 61-4.

8. Asli MR. Iranian Criminal Justice System in Light of International Standards Relating to Victims. European Journal of Crime Criminal Law and Criminal Justice. 2006 Jun 1; 14(2): 185.

9. Mannan, A., Ghani, S., Clarke, A., White, P., Salmanta, S., & Butler, P. E. M. (2006). Psychosocial outcomes derived from an acid burned population in Bangladesh, and comparison with Western norms. Burns, 32(2), 235-241.

10. “Acid Violence in Uganda”- Retrieved from www.acidviolence.org/uploads/filesUganda ASFU Situational Analysis Report FINAL Nov 2011 pdf Grievous Hurt.

11. Kalantry, S., & Getgen, J. E. Combating Acid Violence in Bangladesh, India and Cambodia. Cornell Legal Studies Research Paper, 2011: (11-24).

12. Haque SE, Ahsan H. Human rights violations against women: Acid violence in Bangladesh. American journal of preventive medicine. 2014 Feb 1; 46(2): 216-7.

13. Cleary M, Visentin DC, West S, Say R, McLean L, Kornhaber R. Acid burn attacks: Looking beneath the surface. Journal of advanced nursing. 2018 Jan 24.

14. Kamruzzaman M, Hakim MA. Prevalence of Acid Crime Victimization in South Asia: A Review. Journal of Biological and Environmental Engineering. 2016; 1(2): 17-22.

15. Kuriakose F, Mallick N, Iyer DK. Acid Violence in South Asia: A Structural Analysis toward Transformative Justice. ANTYAJAA: Indian Journal of Women and Social Change. 2017 Jun; 2(1): 65-80.

16. خوارزمی، حنانه، (بی تا)، بررسی جرم اسیدپاشی از نگاه فقه و قانون مجازات اسلامی، پایگاه تحلیلی خبری خانواده و زنان (مهرخانه)، در: [mehrkhaneh.com/fa/new/2901,1391/2/20]

17. Tabriz AA, Dabbagh H, Koenig HG. Medical ethics in qiṣāṣ (eye-for-an-eye) punishment: an Islamic view; an examination of acid throwing. Journal of religion and health. 2016 Aug 1; 55(4): 1426-32.

18. Hafezi, F., Naghibzadeh, B., Nouhi, A. H., & Rad, H. E. (2011). Acid burn violence in Iran. Annals of burns and fire disasters, 24(3), 138.

19. Aghakhani, K., Mehrpisheh, S., Memarian, A., & Nikbin, N. (2013). Epidemiology of caustic burns in Motahari Hospital, Tehran from 2006 to 2011.

20. White PR, Makki M. Crime reporting as storytelling in Persian/Farsi news journalism –perspectives on the narrative function. Journal of World Languages. 2016 May 3; 3(2): 117-38.

21. Zafreen F, Wahab MA, Islam MN, Rahman MA. Socio-demographic characteristics of acid victims in Bangladesh. Journal of Armed Forces Medical College, Bangladesh. 2010; 6(1): 12-5.

22. Chowdhury EH. Negotiating State and NGO Politics in Bangladesh Women Mobilize Against Acid Violence. Violence against women. 2007 Aug 1; 13(8): 857-73.

23. رایجیان اصلی، مهرداد (1390)، افزایش جرم اسیدپاشی در جامعه و لزوم مهار آن، مصاحبه با روزنامۀ حمایت (سازمان زندانها و اقدامات تأمینی و تربیتی کشور).

24. Waldron NR, Kennifer D, Bourgois E, Vanna K, Noor S, Gollogly J. Acid violence in Cambodia: The human, medical and surgical implications. Burns. 2014 Dec 31; 40(8): 1799-804.

25. Mannan A, Ghani S, Clarke A, Butler PE. Cases of chemical assault worldwide: A literature review. Burns. 2007 Mar 31; 33(2): 149-54.

26. Lohray UB. Criminalization of acid crimes and implementing the law in the South East Asian subcontinent. Commonwealth Law Bulletin. 2013 Dec 1; 39(4): 619-30.

27. Nita Bhalla,‘Disfigured Victim’s Plea to Die Exposes India’s Acid Violence’ ThomsonReuters Foundation(New Delhi, 27 July 2012) <http://in.reuters.com/article/2012/07/27/india-acid-attacks-idINDEE 86Q05420120727> accessed 14 June 2013.

28. Compensation Sum Insulting to Acid Attack Victim in Mumbai: Sushma Swaraj’ The Times of India (New Delhi, 3 June 2013).

29. Ahmad N. Acid Attacks on Women: An Appraisal of the Indian Legal Response. Asia-Pac. J. on Hum. Rts. & L. 2011; 12: 55.

30. Daniel Otis,‘Cambodia Failing to Stop Acid

Attacks’ The Star (Siem Reap, 12 January 2013).

31. Huzaimi MF, Jamal J. Acid Splash: Qisas Punishment to Be Imposed Against the Offender. Mimbar Hukum. 2012; 24(3): 377-85.